Not long ago, gravel bikes seemed like a passing fad, a whim, or a remarkable marketing success for big brands. Instead, they've taken the market by storm and become a common sight. They're disappearing from bike shops at breakneck speed (when they do appear – the 2021 season) and, interestingly, they appeal to a remarkably diverse audience. Both adventure enthusiasts and recreational cyclists, looking for something versatile, are lining up. For many, it's also their first experience with a road-derived bike.
It's no wonder gravel pedals raise so many questions. Should I choose platforms ? But is it the right thing to do? On the other hand, SPDs and other clip-in systems are intimidating to most people who haven't used them before. I'll try to explain the advantages of both and point out a few specific models that I think are worth considering. I also encourage you to share your experiences and discuss them.
Platform pedals for gravel
I admit, when I see a road bike with flatbeds, a rare note of conservatism stirs within me, and I give it a snobbery look. Maybe that's how the aging process begins. But let's put aside prejudices and style talk. A significant portion of gravel bike buyers (that word is a bit of a dirty one; I think I prefer "gravel") buy it to ride here and there without a second thought about their outfit. Besides, let's be honest – a five-kilometer bike ride on a bike path isn't exactly a sporting challenge. Clip-in shoes won't change anything, and clicking your cleats in a bar, at work, or at university is a triumph of style over substance.
What to pay attention to and what to choose?
Based on the above arguments, let's start by avoiding all MTB and downhill models. They provide excellent traction, but high metal pins will damage soft-soled shoes. I see two options: wide plastic platform pedals with integrated pins, or more elegant metal ones with a more subtle design. Of the former, my absolute favorite are the BLB Flatliners. My girlfriend uses them for singletrack and I have to say, they're indestructible. The sealed bearings have worked great for another season, and the plastic pins don't wear out and grip any shoe securely. Plus, an accidental hit to the shin won't leave any lasting damage. ;) And if you're looking for a cheaper alternative, we recommend the tried-and-true Authory Slim . We install them frequently and can attest to the excellent price-to-quality ratio. You'll find many similar models on the market.
And what about metal ones? I really appreciate the Japanese MKS bikes . Models with a more modern look will suit gravel riding. They certainly don't evoke associations with MTB. The workmanship and build quality are truly high. They're expensive, but they're a purchase that will last for years.
Which SPD pedals are best for gravel?
If you're planning longer rides and want to fully utilize the potential of your gravel bike, clipless pedals are a must-have. They provide optimal power transfer (especially on climbs) and, above all, a secure connection to the bike in all weather conditions. I recommend giving them a try to skeptics. But which one should you choose? Road-specific systems like SPD-SL are out of the question. They're great for stiffness, but completely ineffective off-road, and you're probably not buying a gravel bike to ride it only on the road? So, you have to turn to MTB and cyclocross.
My pick? Classic Shimano SPD. I realize that opinions on the comfort of various systems are divided. Time's have recently been making a comeback. However, I remain loyal to Japanese products. The reason is simple: durability. Even the cheapest models are truly rugged, perfectly sealed, and, if necessary, fully serviceable. Even models with significant play can usually be salvaged, although even minor ones require inspection and counterbalancing. Fortunately, this doesn't need to be done often – many competing products require bearing replacement more quickly. Good gravel pedals shouldn't be sensitive to dust or high mileage.
What models?
First and foremost, the timeless M520. Simple, solid, and aesthetically pleasing. They offer everything you need, including very precise release force adjustment. They're also easy to service at home. If you're willing to spend a little more, aim high. In my opinion, the best pedals for gravel are Shimano XT. No other series has disappointed me. They're lightweight (contrary to popular belief, you can shave a lot of unnecessary grams off this element), incredibly durable, and have minimal rolling resistance. Plus, they look phenomenal. Why not XTR? For a much higher price, you'll gain only slightly less weight, but they'll take up play much more quickly. And gravel doesn't have to be extremely blinged out at the expense of performance. Let's leave them for XC racing—that's where they excel. And for those who want a road-ready look, there's something else of a curiosity: the PD-ES600 are single-sided, minimalist road pedals compatible with the SPD system. Perfect if you don't expect to get off the bike often.
Gravel pedals - conclusions
Don't be fooled by others, just choose the one that suits your needs. There's also a universal solution. Hybrid pedals – platform on one side, clipless on the other. I think this is the perfect solution. After all, a gravel bike is a versatile bike. So, you can ride in sneakers to work and use cleats on your hikes. Avoid sleek, narrow models. They look nice, but they don't perform well with regular shoes. And in the rain, they're a complete disaster. Of course, I consider the XT series PD-T8000s the best. But even basic models will do the trick. If affordable Japanese products aren't available, you could also consider Accenty Sectors. They're durable, though I find their feel a bit less refined. A plus is that they're easy to clean thanks to the removable outer shell.
If you've had good or bad experiences with any pedals (especially for gravel use), or if you disagree with me, be sure to let me know in the comments! And if you'd like to learn more about the different types of bike pedals or replace them yourself, check out our guide !
Leave a comment